Sunday, March 17, 2013

(An aside)


An article in today's paper sums up the first half of this class nicely. It is the tale of two tire factories in France, one doomed to failure due to a powerful union who will not agree to conditions designed to make the plant more competitive, the other with a future because its workforce is more amenable to change. The prevalent theme: a European country trying to save its industrial base in the face of global economic forces that necessitate massive increases in efficiency (car sales in Europe are the lowest in 20 years) and flexible workers; an objective at odds with a labor force used to the generous conditions of the welfare state. In the context of the theory we have been reading, this story feels like a clash of centuries: the union workers symbolising mid-20th fordism, the restructuring factory acknowledging the reality of 21st century neoliberalism and the global market. I enjoy the juxtaposition of this sad tale of the economic reality of globalisation with an advertisement for a luxury hotel in Miami, the page as a whole symbolising the inequalities created by capitalism on a global scale.

Thursday, March 14, 2013

Segregation, Disinvestment and Decline

Now that we are in a century of unprecedented urbanization, much of the literature related to cities, makes use of the phrase "if present trends continue". For example, "if present trends continue, sometime early next century more than half of the world's population will be classified as urban rather than rural" (David Harvey, writing in 1997). This prediction proved to be accurate. Hollander and Nemeth discuss the forces behind population decline, which variously include globalisation, suburbanization and the natural economic cycle. I’m particularly interested in the cyclical idea. Though there is little doubt that Detroit is a shrinking city, it has been a shrinking city for over half a century now. Though the future certainly does look bleak if present trends continue, there are many examples of cities that have turned around despite similarly bleak predictions, such as Seattle thanks to a whim of Bill Gates. If we had a crystal ball to look into future of rust belt cities, I wonder whether the first nature advantages that became redundant in the 20th Century might prove to be drawcards once more, as climate change threatens powerful coastal cities such as New York. It is important to remember that whilst Detroit may be shrinking, it is also persisting.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

Megacities and Cities of Slums

Mike Davis argues that, in many parts of the world, the absence of large-scale infrastructure projects, suburbia, or powerful manufacturing sectors has forced large swathes of the population into poverty. With the American frontier long closed and postwar waves of migration a relic of the 1950s, in the 21st Century the job of absorbing the excess labor of capitalism has fallen to largely peripheral informal settlements. Furthermore, as Davis points out, “today[’s] surplus labor … faces unprecedented barriers - a literal ‘great wall of high tech border enforcement - blocking large-scale migration to the rich countries.” As the UN’s 2003 report Slums concludes, the insurmountable problems of the Third World have largely been created by the First, through SAP policies that ground economies and public services to a halt. Now, despite a context of drastically decreased worldwide labor mobility, even those who are able to travel to the world’s global cities find the doors to work increasingly closed. Those who manage to defy border controls must eke out a living in the informal economy and live in fear of deportation. Reality TV shows in the UK, US and Australia trivialise the encounters between border control staff and people attempting to enter illegally, where the implied hero is the border control officer and the villain the refugee. Considering the history of First World economic policies that have created this situation, a more truthful representation would see these roles reversed.

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Global Cities / World Cities

As Allen J. Scott writes in Globalisation and the Rise of City-regions, “... some reconsideration of the everyday notion of citizenship is itself long overdue. An alternative definition of citizenship, one that is more fully in harmony with the unfolding new world system, would presumably assign basic political entitlements and obligations to individuals not so much as an absolute birthright, but as some function of their changing involvement and practical allegiances in given geographic contexts.”

While this sentiment makes sense to anyone (myself included) who has grappled with the visa systems of the nation states at the helm of so-called global cities, it is clear that in the decade since this article was written that, if anything, regulation of the non-citizen workforce has become increasingly strict, even polarised. The United Kingdom is an example of a nation characterised by two extremes: mobility of people on the one hand obligated by membership of the EU, and tight regulation on the other that excludes all but the most highly skilled international citizens from working in the UK. What is free movement of peoples across the EU but an extension of entitlements and obligations predicated on birth? This is a regional mobility that can hardly be viewed as global. 
In terms of equity, the EU allows people of all skill levels and economic means, at least theoretically, to live and work anywhere in the union. For non-EU citizens, though, such rights are only granted to those professionals at the top level of command. Thus, mobility itself is an unequal process in the context of a supposedly increasingly globalised economy. It is clear that the political agenda of nation states favours a distinctly regulationist approach over otherwise neoliberal trends when it comes to mobility of labor at a global scale.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Uneven geographies of capitalism

David Harvey argues persuasively that geographic space is not a passive victim of globalisation but an active player in capitalist processes. I was grateful for his clarification of what is meant by ‘contradictions of capitalism’: the idea that physical infrastructure (such as factories and roads) is built to save on time (through distribution channels), only for technological innovation and shifting competition to render these physical structures obsolete. Central to Harvey’s argument is the idea that the built environment is both dynamic and immobile, which he illustrates in terms of jumbo jets: supposedly dynamic, but shackled by the need for airports, runways, and profitable routes. The idea that capitalism leaves a trail of crumbling infrastructure in its wake forgets the many ways in which remnants of capitalist obsolescence have found new relevance in the postindustrial world - the Highline Park being an obvious example - but more subtle reappropriations exist too. Canals, which quickly found themselves obsolete by the expansion of railways in the UK, have been utilised in recent years for laying fibre optic cable. The connectivity we have all come to rely on in the internet age belies the persistence of the complex physical infrastructure required to maintain it. As the capitalist production of space continues increasingly unevenly, facilitated by the minimal intervention of neoliberal governments, it remains to be seen how easily the physical infrastructure of post industrialisation will be repurposed in the future.

Thursday, February 14, 2013

Urban Agglomeration

Last semester, I learned that the economic rationale for the mysterious persistence of cities (agglomerations) in the communication age could be explained simply by the massive externalities created by the generation of tacit knowledge. Of course, this rationale applies to growth-generating cities such as New York or Boston, rather than cities experiencing economic decline; the idea being that tacit knowledge is gained through the proximity of people and firms (where constant innovation generates increasing returns to scale) whereas knowledge that can be replicated can also be outsourced (and thus dispersed) to regions with cheaper labor. This week’s readings demonstrate that explaining capitalist economic growth in the context of the wider political and social forces that shape cities is far messier exercise. For example, Joe Painter discusses the nascent application of regulation theory to urban theory, and attempts to define the “Mode of Regulation” of post-Fordism using examples from local government in Britain. Crudely, this involves a shift from centralised, process-driven ‘Fordist’ government to something more decentralised, outcome-driven and neo-liberal. It is easy to see why regulation theory appeals to urban theorists for supposedly taking account of political and social change, but its premise that the instabilities of capitalism are ironed out by forces that are neither conscious nor accidental and usually unintended (Modes of Regulation) surely renders the task of definition extremely difficult, and makes me wonder how this theory can be usefully applied.

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Urban questions and epistemologies

When I was 15, one day in English class our teacher asked the question of an entirely female classroom, “who here would describe themselves as a feminist?” Everyone looked confused and hesitated. The teacher looked shocked. “What if I told you”, she said, “that a feminist is somebody who believes in equality between the sexes?” All hands shot up. It was the first time the concept of feminism had been succinctly explained, and ever since I’ve been deeply annoyed by women who don’t describe themselves as feminists because they either don’t understand the concept, or don’t wish to be seen as political. Australian supermodel Miranda Kerr caught my attention most recently for stating in an interview that she was not a feminist. While celebrities declaring themselves not to be feminists is irritating, I would expect better from sociologists. I was very surprised to learn that only 5 out of 26 female academics in the Chicago school interviewed by Mary Jo Deegan would agree with her assessment of the Sociology Department as highly patriarchal in outlook and practice, despite the clear evidence Deegan presents in her critique of the School’s “dark era”. If women in all professions are to move closer to equality, surely the lesson of this article is that, at the very least, they should not be complicit in their own exclusion.